Voluntary Self-Disclosure in U.S. Export Compliance
Introduction to Voluntary Self-Disclosure (VSD)
Voluntary self-disclosure (VSD) is a critical tool for companies that discover violations of U.S. export control regulations, including the Export Administration Regulations (EAR) and the International Traffic in Arms Regulations (ITAR). When a company identifies a potential or actual breach of these regulations, voluntarily disclosing the violation to the appropriate U.S. government agency—such as the Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS) or the Directorate of Defense Trade Controls (DDTC)—can significantly reduce the penalties associated with the violation.
Why VSD Is Important
Voluntary self-disclosure is a proactive step that demonstrates a company’s commitment to compliance and its willingness to cooperate with regulatory authorities. By promptly reporting violations, companies can mitigate the consequences and often avoid more severe penalties that could result from regulatory investigations.
Key benefits of VSD include:
Penalty Mitigation: U.S. regulatory agencies, such as BIS and DDTC, typically consider VSD as a mitigating factor when determining penalties. Companies that voluntarily disclose violations often face reduced fines and penalties compared to those that are found to have committed violations through investigations.
Demonstrating Good Faith: Voluntary self-disclosure shows that a company is acting in good faith and takes its compliance obligations seriously. This can help build a more favorable relationship with regulatory authorities.
Avoiding Criminal Charges: In some cases, VSD can help a company avoid criminal charges by demonstrating that the violation was not intentional and that the company is committed to corrective actions.
The Process of Voluntary Self-Disclosure
The process of voluntary self-disclosure involves several key steps:
Identify and Assess the Violation: The first step is to identify and assess the potential violation. This includes determining the scope of the violation, the regulations involved, and the potential impact on the company.
Gather Documentation: Companies should gather all relevant documentation related to the violation, including export records, communications, and internal reports. This documentation will be crucial for the VSD submission.
Submit the Disclosure: The company must submit a detailed disclosure to the appropriate agency, typically BIS for EAR violations or DDTC for ITAR violations. The disclosure should include a thorough explanation of the violation, the circumstances surrounding it, and the steps the company has taken or will take to correct it.
Cooperate with Authorities: After submitting the VSD, the company should be prepared to cooperate fully with regulatory authorities. This may involve providing additional information, responding to inquiries, and implementing corrective actions as recommended by the agency.
Implement Corrective Actions: To further mitigate penalties and improve compliance, companies should implement corrective actions, such as revising compliance procedures, conducting additional training, or enhancing internal controls.
Consequences of Not Disclosing
Failing to voluntarily disclose a violation can lead to more severe consequences, including:
Increased Penalties: If a violation is discovered through a regulatory investigation rather than voluntary disclosure, the company is likely to face higher fines and penalties.
Criminal Charges: Non-disclosure can lead to criminal charges, particularly if the violation is found to be intentional or part of a broader pattern of non-compliance.
Reputational Damage: Companies that fail to disclose violations risk damaging their reputation with customers, partners, and regulators, which can lead to loss of business opportunities.
Conclusion
Voluntary self-disclosure is a vital component of export compliance, offering companies the opportunity to mitigate penalties and demonstrate their commitment to adhering to U.S. export control regulations. By proactively identifying and reporting violations, companies can avoid more severe consequences and maintain stronger relationships with regulatory authorities.
—
Sources Cited
- Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS). "Guidelines for Voluntary Self-Disclosure." https://www.bis.doc.gov/index.php/compliance-a-training/export-management-a-compliance/10-compliance/659-guidelines-for-voluntary-self-disclosure
- Directorate of Defense Trade Controls (DDTC). "Voluntary Disclosures." https://www.pmddtc.state.gov/ddtc_public?id=ddtc_kb_article_page&sys_id=0216c95bdbbc9300d0a370131f961941
- United States Department of Justice. "Export Control and Sanctions Enforcement." https://www.justice.gov/nsd/export-control-and-sanctions
